Quick Answer
Most cash offers in San Antonio come in below what the home would bring in a conventional listing, often in the range of 10% to 25% under market, because the cash buyer is paying for speed, no repairs, and no financing risk. The exact number depends on your home's condition, your market, and who the cash buyer is.
A cash offer is a trade: the buyer takes on the risk and the work, and they price the home for that. Investors, iBuyers, and flippers each use a formula that starts with what the home would sell for in good condition, subtracts repair costs, carrying costs, and a profit margin, and lands below a retail sale.
The exception is a retail cash buyer, someone buying the home to live in who happens to pay cash. Those offers can match a financed offer because the buyer is competing on the same market. The key is knowing which kind of cash buyer is on the other side of the offer, and the price usually tells you.
Where the discount comes from
Investor cash buyers subtract three things from the retail price: repairs and upgrades, carrying costs while they hold the home, and their profit. A home that needs $30,000 of work often sees a cash offer that is $30,000 plus some margin below what a move-in-ready buyer would pay.
iBuyers price on a similar formula but add convenience: you skip showings, repairs, and the listing process in exchange for a below-market number. None of that makes the offer unfair, it is just a different product. You are selling certainty instead of profit.
Compare the cash offer to your net on a listing
The right comparison is not list price versus cash offer. It is the cash offer versus what you would actually net from a listing after commission, concessions, repairs, and the risk of a deal falling through. A $20,000 lower cash offer can beat a listing net once you subtract everything a retail sale costs.
Run both numbers before you decide. My page on what it costs to sell in Texas lists the deductions a listing sale carries.
Ask who the cash buyer is
Ask the buyer or their agent whether they will occupy the home, rent it, or flip it. The answer changes the negotiation. A flipper needs margin and will push hard. A retail cash buyer competes on value like any buyer, and a renter will buy at close to market because the numbers work over time.
You should also ask how the cash is verified with a proof of funds letter, because a cash offer without funds behind it is just talk. My guide to proof of funds letters explains what a real one looks like.
Patrick's cash offer checklist
Evaluating a Cash Offer
- ✓Verify the funds with a proof of funds letter from the buyer's bank.
- ✓Ask who the buyer is: owner, investor, or iBuyer.
- ✓Compare the net cash offer to the net of a full listing.
- ✓Subtract repairs, commission, concessions, and carrying costs from the listing net.
- ✓Ask about closing speed and whether the buyer will waive the inspection.
- ✓Get the offer in writing with a clear closing timeline.
Ask Patrick what your cash offer is worth
Get a straight answer on what a cash buyer would pay for your home and whether to take it.
