New Construction

Why Do Property Taxes Jump the Second Year on a New Construction Home?

Patrick Kevin Fagan

Texas Real Estate Sales Agent #454749, AXEN Realty LLC · Senior Loan Officer, NMLS ID #877741, NEXA Mortgage, LLC

Updated November 9, 2026

Quick Answer

Your first property tax bill on a new build is based on the land value, because Texas appraisal districts value property as of January 1, before the house existed. The next January 1 the finished home is added at full market value, and your lender's annual escrow analysis turns that higher tax bill into a higher monthly payment. Plan a cushion, file your homestead as soon as you qualify, and protest any value you believe is too high. Ask Patrick to estimate your first and second year tax bills.

Texas appraisal districts value every property as of January 1 of each tax year, based on the condition of the property on that date (Texas Comptroller, Texas property tax basics). If your new home was not complete and habitable on January 1, the district values only the land or a partially built structure, so the first bill looks small.

The next January 1 the finished house exists, so the district adds the home at full market value as a new improvement. That is the tax spike new construction owners describe, and it lands the same year your lender's mandatory annual escrow analysis catches the gap and raises your payment. It is a normal part of the Texas system, not a mistake, and you can plan for it.

Why your first property tax bill on a new build is low

Texas appraisal districts value every property as of January 1 of each tax year, based on what exists on the property that date (Texas Comptroller, Texas property tax basics). If the house was not complete and habitable on January 1, the district values only the land, or a partially built structure, and that is the value behind your first tax bill.

Your lender builds the monthly escrow payment from the tax bill available at closing, and for a new build that is usually the land-only amount. Close in the middle of the year and you may also see a prorated first bill based on that partial value, which makes year one look small. It is not a discount. It is just the starting value.

The exact appraised value on a property is public. Check your appraisal district's records by address: Bexar County values are on BCAD.org, and each Texas county has its own appraisal district site. Look up the address before you set your expectations, not after.

The reality check

The jump feels large because you are paying, for the first time, on the full completed value of the home, land and house together. That is how the Texas system works, and it is not a penalty.

Why year two is the spike year

The next January 1, the finished house exists, so the appraisal district adds the home to the tax rolls at full market value as a new improvement. The value on the books moves from the lot to the completed home, and that is the single biggest value change most new builds ever see on a tax statement.

This is also why the 10 percent appraisal cap does not protect you in that first reassessment year. Texas law caps annual value growth at 10 percent only after a homestead exemption is in place (Texas Tax Code 23.23, per the Texas Comptroller). A brand new improvement is added at full value before the cap can apply, so the cap protects later years, not the first full-value year.

Patrick's Tip

Ask your lender in writing what tax value the year-one escrow estimate uses. If the estimate is based on the land only, you now know exactly which number will change the second year.

How the escrow analysis turns the tax jump into a payment jump

Federal mortgage servicing rules require your loan servicer to run a trial running balance escrow analysis at least once every 12 months (Regulation X, 12 CFR 1024.17, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau). The analysis projects the coming year's tax and insurance payments against what is actually in your escrow account. After the tax bill jumps, the account comes up short, and that shortfall is the escrow shortage.

When the shortage is at least one month's escrow payment, the servicer raises your monthly escrow collection to the new, higher tax amount and spreads the repayment in equal monthly amounts across the next 12 months or longer. Both changes hit the same monthly payment, which is why the number on your statement goes up so noticeably.

The CFPB's rules also cap the escrow cushion a servicer can hold at one sixth of the total annual escrow payments, roughly two months' worth, and require the servicer to mail the escrow analysis statement explaining the shortage within 30 days. Read that letter. It shows exactly what changed and what the new payment covers.

I explain the general version of the escrow shortage in my answer on what an escrow shortage is and why your payment went up. This page covers why new construction gets hit harder than a resale purchase.

When the homestead exemption helps, and when it does not

The homestead exemption is the main lever you control. To receive it for a tax year, you must own and occupy the home as your principal residence on January 1 of that year, and you must file with the county appraisal district by April 30. In Bexar County that means Bexar Appraisal District Form 50-114, filed online at bcad.org (Bexar Appraisal District, checked November 9, 2026).

Close and move in after January 1, and you claim the exemption the following year. Texas Tax Code 11.431 lets you file late and have the exemption applied retroactively for up to two prior tax years, so missing the April 30 deadline does not permanently cost you the exemption.

The homestead exemption lowers the taxable value and starts the 10 percent cap, but it does not cancel the year-two jump. The jump comes from the land-to-full-home value change, which happens before the exempt status matters. Expect the full-value year, then let the exemption and the cap smooth out the years after.

For the full mechanics, see my answer on what the Texas homestead exemption is and how to file for it.

Patrick's New-Build Tax Checklist

  • ✓Confirm in writing what value your year-one escrow is based on, and whether it is land only.
  • ✓Look up the school district and county tax rates for the address on the appraisal district's website.
  • ✓Project year two the same way the district will: the completed home's market value times the rate that applies to your address, then compare it with what year one charged you.
  • ✓Mark the homestead dates: own and occupy by January 1, file by April 30.
  • ✓Set aside a separate cushion during year one for the likely escrow shortage.
  • ✓Read every escrow analysis statement within 30 days of receipt.

Bexar County homestead filings use Bexar Appraisal District Form 50-114 at bcad.org. Other Texas counties use their own appraisal district forms (checked November 9, 2026).

What to do about it, before and after closing

The fix starts before you close: confirm what tax value the first year's escrow uses, project the full-value year using the rates for your address, and put a cushion in your plan. Your exact tax bill is driven by your address, so check the official source or have Patrick walk through the estimate with you.

If the jump already landed, you still have options. You can protest the appraised value with the appraisal review board each year by the deadline printed on your notice of appraised value, and you can appeal again every year. In Texas the protest deadline is generally May 15, or 30 days after the notice is delivered, whichever is later (Texas Property Tax Code 41.44).

Your options for the escrow shortage itself: pay it as a lump sum and your payment only rises to the new normal, or spread it across the next 12 months and accept the higher payment for a year. Filing the homestead and protesting a value you believe is too high are the two levers that change the number going forward.

For the full San Antonio calendar of protest dates and steps, see the timeline for protesting property taxes in San Antonio.

New-build tax questions buyers actually ask

These are the questions I hear most from buyers sitting across from a new construction contract, answered in one or two lines each.

Quick answers on new-build taxes

Is this the same thing as an escrow shortage?

It is the cause of the escrow shortage on most new builds. The general mechanics are on my escrow shortage page; the new construction version starts with the land-only value.

Does the 10 percent cap protect my new build?

Not in the first full-value year. The cap applies after the homestead exemption is in place, and new improvements are added at full market value first.

Can I file the homestead late?

Yes. Texas Tax Code 11.431 allows a late filing that applies the exemption retroactively for up to two prior tax years. File the moment you occupy.

How do I find my address's tax rate?

Look up the adopted rate for the school district and county that serve your address on the appraisal district's website. Rates apply by address, so check the official source.

Ask Patrick to estimate your new-build taxes

Get a realistic view of your first and second year tax bills before you choose a lot or sign with a builder.

By submitting, you agree Patrick may contact you by phone, email, or text about your question. Consent is not a condition of purchasing any product or service.

Patrick's Take

The second-year tax jump on a new build is not a mistake and not a failure of your loan. Texas values the land one year and the finished home the next. The buyers who plan for it file their homestead on time, set aside a cushion, and read every escrow analysis letter that arrives.
PF
Patrick Kevin Fagan

Plan for Year Two Before You Close

Ask Patrick to walk through the projected tax bill and escrow cushion on the new build you are considering, before you sign.

Text Patrick at 210-317-6514 or take the next step here.

Answered by Patrick Kevin Fagan

Texas Real Estate Sales Agent #454749, AXEN Realty LLC · Senior Loan Officer, NMLS ID #877741, NEXA Mortgage, LLC

Call or text: 210-317-6514